A 13-gallon square trash can is the kitchen standard for a reason — it holds a full day of family food prep waste, fits standard tall kitchen bags without sagging, and slides neatly into a cabinet cutout or against a counter. The square shape also maximizes every inch of floor space compared to a round bin, leaving less wasted air around the bag. But the real debate starts when you have to choose how that lid opens: press-top, swing-top, step pedal, or motion sensor. Each mechanism changes how often you touch the bin, how much noise it makes, and how it holds up over hundreds of daily cycles.
I’m Mohammad — the founder and writer behind ProteinJug. I’ve spent many hours researching and analyzing the build quality, opening mechanisms, and long-term durability of the best-selling 13-gallon square trash cans on the market to help you find the right fit for your home.
Whether you want a simple hands-free pedal or a touchless sensor lid, this guide breaks down the pros, cons, and real-world trade-offs of the top contenders so you can confidently choose your ideal 13 gallon square trash can.
How To Choose The Best 13 Gallon Square Trash Can
A 13-gallon square trash can sounds simple, but small differences in lid mechanism, material, and shape compatibility determine whether it becomes a joy to use or a daily annoyance. Focus on these three areas before checking out.
Lid Mechanism: Touch, Step, or Wave
The lid is the most interacted-with part of any kitchen trash can. Press-tops and swing-tops are cheapest and mechanically simple but require a hand touch — consider how often your hands are messy from cooking. Step pedals offer hands-free operation without batteries but take up extra floor space in front of the can. Motion sensors are the most convenient for full hands but introduce batteries, sensors, and motors that can fail over time. Match the mechanism to your kitchen workflow: if you prep a lot of raw meat, a pedal or sensor is worth the upgrade.
Material: Plastic vs. Stainless Steel
High-density plastic bins like those from Sterilite are lightweight, crack-resistant, and easy to wipe down, but they can absorb odors if not cleaned regularly and feel less premium. Stainless steel models are heavier, more durable, and better at resisting odors and fingerprints — especially brushed or fingerprint-proof finishes. The tradeoff is weight: a steel 13-gallon can weighs around 20 pounds, which makes it harder to move for deep cleaning but also less likely to tip over when the bag is full.
Shape and Bag Fit
Not all square cans are the same width and depth. A truly square or rectangular base ensures standard 13-gallon kitchen bags fit snugly without slipping down inside the can — a common frustration with tapered or round bins. Look for dimensions close to 15–16 inches wide and 10–12 inches deep, and a height around 25–28 inches. Some models include a removable inner bucket that lifts out for easier bag changes, which saves you from wrestling the liner out of a deep bin.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ELPHECO Stainless Steel Pedal Can | Stainless Steel | Hands-free quiet kitchen use | 21.5 lb build weight, soft-close lid | Amazon |
| iTouchless Sensor Lid Replacement | Touchless Sensor | Upgrading an existing iTouchless can | PetGuard lock, VisioSense tech | Amazon |
| SIMPLI-MAGIC Touchless Sensor Can | Touchless Plastic | Budget smart can with odor seal | 5.95 lb lightweight plastic body | Amazon |
| Sterilite Swing-Top Black | Swing-Top Plastic | Garage or utility room durability | 28″ height for tall bag clearance | Amazon |
| Sterilite Touch Can White | Press-Top Plastic | Entry-level affordability | 3.6 lb light, crack-resistant plastic | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. ELPHECO Stainless Steel Pedal Can (13 Gallon / 50L)
The ELPHECO pedal can hits the sweet spot between premium build and real-world practicality. The brushed stainless steel body resists fingerprints and odors better than glossy plastic, and the 21.5-pound weight keeps the can planted even when the bag is stuffed with a full 24-pound dog food bag. The foot pedal is wide enough to operate with a slipper or bare foot, and the soft-close lid eliminates the clatter that cheap swing-tops make at night. It also includes a removable inner bucket that lifts out for bag changes, which saves you from wrestling the liner out of a deep bin.
Owners consistently praise the quiet closing action and the included 20 starter trash bags that fit perfectly. The 90-degree stay-open lid mode is useful during meal prep when you need both hands free, and the rectangular footprint is compact enough for a standard under-counter cabinet. A few users note the lid hinge feels a bit stiff initially, especially for opening with one hand, but it loosens up after a few cycles. The brushed finish does show some water spots over time, but a quick wipe restores the look.
For anyone who wants a durable, no-battery-needed, hands-free kitchen can that won’t tip over or slam shut, the ELPHECO is the most balanced choice in this lineup. It combines the stability of steel with the practical features — soft-close, inner bucket, stay-open mode — that make daily use genuinely better, not just more expensive.
Why it’s great
- Soft-close lid is whisper-quiet and prevents slamming
- Removable inner bucket makes liner changes effortless
- Heavy steel construction resists tipping and odors
Good to know
- Starter trash bags are thin — replace with standard 13-gallon bags
- Pedal requires a firm push; not the lightest touch
2. iTouchless Sensor Lid Replacement (Models IT13MX, DZT13P, etc.)
The iTouchless replacement lid is a clever solution for anyone whose original sensor lid broke or whose can base is still perfectly good. Instead of throwing away a whole bin, you swap in this lid and get upgraded VisioSense motion detection, Reflx technology that prevents it from closing on your hand, and the PetGuard lock feature that stops dogs from pawing the lid open. The soft-close mechanism is noticeably quieter than the earlier iTouchless versions and the earlier SIMPLI-MAGIC models. Power comes from four D batteries (not included) that last up to a year and a half with normal use.
Customers who bought it as a replacement report that installation takes about five minutes and restores their can to like-new function. The lid fits most iTouchless 13-gallon square bases, including models IT13MX, IT13MXL, DZT13P, DZT13PL, and DZT13M. The Stay-Open mode is handy for longer cleaning sessions, and the manual open/close buttons work as a backup if the sensor gets blocked by a tall bag. A small but persistent minority report that the internal plastic lever that drives the lid mechanism can snap after a year or two of use, which is the same failure pattern as the original lid — so you may be buying this same replacement again down the road.
This is not a full can; it is a precision replacement part for a specific set of iTouchless bases. If your base is still in good shape and you want the latest sensor features without buying a whole new bin, this lid delivers reliable touchless convenience. Just be aware that the plastic gear inside is the component most likely to fail again over time.
Why it’s great
- Five-minute installation restores a broken can to new condition
- PetGuard lock effectively prevents animal access to trash
- Long battery life — up to 18 months on four D cells
Good to know
- Only fits specific iTouchless models — not universal
- Internal plastic lever can still snap over time
3. SIMPLI-MAGIC 13 Gallon Touchless Sensor Trash Can
The SIMPLI-MAGIC touchless can brings sensor lid convenience to a lower price tier. Wave your hand over the top and the lid opens automatically — helpful when your hands are full of food scraps or you’re wearing messy gloves. The lid also has a manual mode if you prefer to press a button, and the odor-seal ring around the rim does a decent job of trapping smells inside. The white plastic body is lightweight at under 6 pounds, making it easy to move for cleaning, but it also means the can can tip if you bump it with a heavy bag inside.
Customer feedback is split along a predictable line: early adopters love the touchless convenience and modern look, but multiple long-term reviews report that the sensor mechanism fails after a year or two, often when the batteries are fresh. The lid lift mechanism is a clear plastic arm that can crack, and the motorized opening can become unreliable. The lid also closes with a noticeable clunk rather than a soft hush — several owners note it is not a soft-close mechanism. On the plus side, the rectangular body is compact enough for a guest bathroom or small kitchen, and the white finish hides scuffs reasonably well.
If you want to try a sensor can for a lower entry cost and are okay with the possibility of replacing it within two years, the SIMPLI-MAGIC offers the experience without the premium spend. It is best suited for light to moderate use in a low-traffic area, not as the primary kitchen workhorse for a busy family.
Why it’s great
- Touchless opening works well for hands-free kitchen tasks
- Lightweight body is easy to relocate and clean
- Odor-seal lid contains smells better than open baskets
Good to know
- Sensor mechanism is prone to failure within 1–2 years
- Lid closes loudly, not a soft-close action
4. Sterilite Wastebasket Swing-Top Black (13 Gallon / 10899004)
The Sterilite 13-gallon swing-top is the no-frills workhorse of this list. The black plastic body is thick and crack-resistant, and the swing lid opens with a simple push — no batteries, no sensors, no pedals to break. At 28 inches tall, it is one of the tallest options here, which gives you extra clearance for tall bags and makes it comfortable to toss trash from a standing position. The rectangular shape fits standard 13-gallon kitchen bags without the bag slipping down inside the can.
Reviews consistently call it sturdy and good value, but there is a consistent design note: the swing top does not always close on its own. Several owners report needing to add a small weight or washer to the back of the lid to get it to swing shut by gravity. This is a minor mod but worth knowing if a self-closing lid is important to you. The polished black finish is fingerprint-resistant, and the plastic is easy to wipe down without rust concerns — ideal for a garage, mudroom, or workshop where spills and dirt are common.
For buyers who want an affordable, long-lasting, dead-simple can that can handle abuse and doesn’t need tech support, the Sterilite swing-top delivers. It is not fancy, but it is the kind of product you buy once and forget about — which is exactly what a utility trash can should be.
Why it’s great
- Thick, crack-resistant plastic can take a beating in a garage or workshop
- Tall 28-inch height works well with standard tall kitchen bags
- No batteries, motors, or sensors to fail over time
Good to know
- Swing lid may not close on its own — may need a DIY weight mod
- Not fingerprint-proof, but black color hides grime well
5. Sterilite Touch Can, White, 13 Gallon (10458004)
The Sterilite Touch Can is the most affordable entry point into a covered 13-gallon square bin. The press-top lid opens by pushing down on the center, and the bright white plastic body is lightweight at just 3.6 pounds — easy to carry out to the curb on trash day. The crack-resistant material holds up well to daily use, and the polished finish wipes clean with a damp cloth. Multiple reviews call it sturdy and a perfect fit for laundry rooms, small kitchens, or as a dedicated diaper pail for cloth diapers and wipes.
The main tradeoff for the low cost is the lid mechanism. The press-top can be sensitive — a bump from the side can pop it open, and some units arrive with a lid latch that does not snap closed properly, requiring a return or a DIY fix like a velcro strap. The lid itself is also not designed to stay open on its own, so you have to hold it with one hand while tossing trash, which is less convenient than an open-top or pedal can for meal prep. On the plus side, the simple design means there is almost nothing to break — no springs, no hinges, no motors — just a plastic top that sits on a plastic bin.
If you need a basic covered can for a guest bathroom, small office, or utility closet and want to spend the absolute least, the Sterilite Touch Can does the job. Just check the lid latch immediately upon arrival, and be prepared for the occasional pop-open if the can is bumped in a tight space.
Why it’s great
- Extremely lightweight at 3.6 lbs — easy to move and empty
- Simple press-top design has no components to break
- Bright white finish looks clean in laundry rooms and small spaces
Good to know
- Lid latch can arrive defective on some units — inspect immediately
- Press-top is sensitive to accidental bumps that pop the lid open
FAQ
Do standard 13-gallon kitchen bags fit square trash cans?
Why does my swing-top lid not close by itself?
How long do motion sensor trash can lids last before breaking?
Is stainless steel or plastic better for odor control?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best 13 gallon square trash can is the ELPHECO Stainless Steel Pedal Can because it combines a stable steel build, a soft-close lid, a removable inner bucket, and completely battery-free hands-free operation. If you want to upgrade an existing iTouchless can with the latest sensor technology, grab the iTouchless Replacement Lid. And for a bulletproof, no-tech utility can that can take a beating in the garage, nothing beats the Sterilite Swing-Top Black.