Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.7 Best 5 Inch Gym Shorts | Built-in Liners That Actually Work

Check Price on Amazon

The Maamgic 2-in-1 shorts earn the top spot because they nail the liner tension sweet spot — tight enough to prevent thigh chafing during long runs yet flexible enough for deep yoga stretches. The 86% polyester / 14% spandex shell feels noticeably softer than standard athletic mesh fabrics, and the 5-inch inseam lands precisely at mid-thigh for most body types without riding up during squats. Customers report zero degradation after nine months of machine washing and drying, which is exceptional for the price tier.

The pocket layout deserves special mention: side pockets include small internal compartments for energy gels or earbuds, and the rear zippered pocket fits a wallet or ID without adding bulk. The built-in compression liner eliminates the need for separate underwear, and multiple reviews confirm the “going commando” experience is comfortable and chafe-free. At 5’11” and 200 pounds, a large fits snugly without restriction, though runners with very strong legs may want to size up if they prefer a looser liner.

One caveat: the liner is less compressive than dedicated compression shorts, so if you’re prone to liner migration during sprints, this may not be your first choice. However, for the vast majority of gym-goers who want a single pair that handles lifting, running, and casual wear, these are the most versatile option available.

Check Price on Amazon

Nike’s Flex Stride 2-in-1 is the benchmark that other lined shorts are measured against, and for good reason. The Dri-FIT mesh upper is engineered for maximum breathability — air moves through the fabric almost as if you were wearing nothing, making these ideal for hot outdoor runs or poorly ventilated gyms. The built-in brief liner stays put during sprints and interval work, and multiple buyers confirm the shorts feel “just as described” regarding fit and comfort.

The 5-inch inseam is aggressive enough to reveal full quad extension during strides, and the split hem at the side allows unrestricted hip rotation. Reflective details add visibility for early morning or evening runs, and the waistband sits flat under a lifting belt. Customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers noting the shorts work equally well for running and general gym sessions.

The main tradeoff is price — these sit at the premium end of the market, and while the fabric quality justifies the cost, you’re paying for the brand name and the proven Dri-FIT technology. The pocket situation is also minimal: there’s a single zippered pocket at the back that fits a phone, but no side pockets for quick access to keys or a gym card.

Check Price on Amazon

The CRZ Yoga Dolphin shorts have become a cult favorite among women who refuse to compromise between running performance and everyday comfort. The fabric is a soft, quick-drying woven shell that feels almost like cotton but dries in minutes after a heavy sweat session. The mid-rise waistband hits at a flattering position that doesn’t dig in during long runs, and the 5-inch inseam provides ample coverage for women around 5’2″ without looking baggy.

Multiple reviewers specifically mention these as “amazing dupes” for name brands costing three times as much, noting the quality is nearly identical except for the logo. The built-in liner is breathable and stays in place without riding up — a common complaint in cheaper women’s shorts. Dark colors show no sweat marks, and the fabric holds its shape after repeated washes without pilling. At a 33-inch waist, the XL fits without squeezing, suggesting the sizing runs slightly generous.

The only consistent criticism is the pocket: a single small zip pocket that fits a key or card but not a modern smartphone. For women who carry their phone during runs, this is a genuine limitation. Additionally, the shorts are unlined, so you’ll need to wear separate underwear or a liner if you prefer the compression feel.

Check Price on Amazon

CRZ Yoga brings the same quality-to-price ratio from their women’s line into men’s 2-in-1 shorts, and the result is a strong competitor to Lululemon and Vuori at roughly half the price. The outer shell uses a lightweight woven fabric that feels smooth against the skin, and the built-in compression liner provides enough support for most gym activities without feeling restrictive. Customers consistently compare these favorably to premium brands, noting the fit and construction are nearly indistinguishable.

The 5-inch inseam works well for cross-training, yoga, and even casual sports like pickleball and biking. Side pockets are deep enough to hold a phone securely during movement, and the drawstring waistband ensures a custom fit without cinching too tight. At 5’10” and 175 pounds, a medium fits true to size, with enough room in the thigh for squats without being baggy.

Where these fall short is the liner material — it’s not as quick-drying as the outer shell, so after intense cardio the liner can stay damp longer than desired. Some buyers also note the outer fabric has a slight “plasticky” feel that doesn’t breathe as well as mesh alternatives. If you prioritize fabric feel over cost savings, these may not be your first choice.

Check Price on Amazon

If fabric feel is your top priority, the Maamgic unlined stretch shorts deliver a “silky soft” hand feel that almost feels like a blend between cotton and performance polyester. The 86% polyester / 14% spandex blend provides four-way stretch that moves with you through deep squats and lunges without any binding, and the 5.5-inch inseam offers slightly more coverage than the true 5-inch options. Multiple customers describe these as the “softest, stretchiest, most comfortable shorts” they’ve ever owned — high praise from the gym community.

The pocket configuration is genuinely thoughtful: a zippered front pocket that fits keys, a deep unzippered front pocket for wallet, and a rear zippered pocket that can hold an iPhone vertically. A small internal pocket in the left side is perfect for contact lenses or an earbud case. At 5’11” and 167 pounds, a medium fits perfectly without being constricting, and the elastic waistband accommodates sizes without needing the drawstring.

These shorts lack a built-in liner, so you’ll need to wear compression shorts or briefs underneath if you prefer the lined experience. Some buyers also note the sizing runs slightly small, so checking the size chart carefully before ordering is recommended. For lifters who prioritize unrestricted movement and pocket space over built-in liners, these are an outstanding choice.

Check Price on Amazon

The Real Essentials 4-pack is the ultimate gym wardrobe foundation — you get four pairs in different colors for roughly the price of one premium short, making this the obvious choice for anyone building a rotation from scratch. The mesh fabric is highly breathable and dries quickly, and the 5-inch inseam hits just above the knee for a classic athletic look. Big and tall sizing options make this accessible for larger athletes who struggle to find 5-inch shorts that fit.

The zippered pockets are a standout feature at this price point — front pockets include zippers to secure your phone and keys during intense workouts. Customers at 5’10” and 340 pounds report these fit well and don’t ride up the leg, which speaks to the generous cut. The shorts hold up well after multiple washes, with no significant fading or pilling reported.

The main compromises are in pocket depth and zipper quality. The front pockets are on the shallower side, and the zippers are not YKK-grade — several reviews mention zipper failure over time. The waistband sizing can also be inconsistent; a medium fits snugly on a 5’3″ athletic female, suggesting men may want to size up one or two sizes from their normal fit. For the price per pair, these issues are manageable, but serious lifters may want to upgrade for more durable construction.

Check Price on Amazon

New Balance brings decades of athletic wear expertise to these Sport Essentials mesh shorts, and the result is a reliable, no-frills option for lifters who prefer a classic loose fit. The mesh fabric is noticeably thicker and more substantial than budget alternatives, offering durability without sacrificing breathability. The 5-inch inseam is true to measurement and provides the exact “short king approved” length that shorter athletes love — allowing quad definition to show without looking like briefs.

The loose cut is generous through the hip and thigh, making these a great choice for those with larger lower bodies or anyone who dislikes a compressive feel during training. At 5’8″ and 223 pounds, an extra large fits comfortably without squeezing, and the thick mesh doesn’t go see-through when wet. The elastic waistband with external drawstring ensures a secure fit that stays put during dynamic movements.

The mesh fabric, while durable, lacks the stretch and softness of polyester-spandex blends, so you won’t get the same unrestricted mobility during deep squats or lunges. Some buyers note the fit feels “awkward” or “functional but not great,” and the pockets are basic without zippers, meaning your phone can bounce out during box jumps or sprints. For the classic New Balance experience at a premium price point, you’re paying for brand heritage and durability rather than cutting-edge performance features.