That deep, throbbing ache under the skin is hard to ignore. A boil can make sitting, sleeping, or even wearing certain clothes feel unbearable. The right boil remedy focuses on drawing the infection to the surface and relieving that pressure, speeding up the body’s natural healing process without harsh intervention.
I’m Mohammad — the founder and writer behind ProteinJug. I spend my time analyzing ingredient concentration, formulation science, and user-reported outcomes across hundreds of first-aid and skincare products to find what actually works for stubborn skin conditions.
After sifting through decades of product data, ingredient profiles, and thousands of real user reviews, I’ve narrowed down the top options to help you find the best boil remedy for your specific situation — whether you need fast pain relief, a natural drawing action, or a budget-friendly standby for your medicine cabinet.
How To Choose The Best Boil Remedy
Not all boil remedies work the same way. Your choice hinges on the boil’s stage — is it a deep, painful lump under the skin, or has it already come to a head? Selecting the wrong type can prolong the healing cycle.
Drawing Salves vs. Pain-Relieving Ointments
A drawing salve contains ingredients like Ichthammol or activated charcoal that pull infection and debris toward the skin’s surface. These are best for deep, un-ruptured boils. Pain-relieving ointments, on the other hand, use a topical analgesic like Benzocaine to numb the area and manage the throbbing, making them ideal for boils that are already surfaced and causing intense discomfort.
Active Ingredient Strength & Formulation
For drawing salves, a 10% Ichthammol concentration is considered the standard for effective drawing. For pain relief, a 20% Benzocaine solution provides maximum-strength numbing without a prescription. Look for formulations that are free of unnecessary fillers and designed for external use only. The texture matters too — a creamy ointment stays in place better than a thin liquid.
Natural vs. Medicated Approaches
Homeopathic options rely on diluted natural ingredients to stimulate the body’s own healing response. These are worth considering if you prefer a gentle approach, but they work slower than medicated alternatives. Medicated ointments provide faster, more predictable relief, making them the smarter choice for acute pain management.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boil Ease Pain Relieving Ointment | Medicated Ointment | Numbing active boil pain | Benzocaine 20% | Amazon |
| Smile’s Prid Drawing Salve | Homeopathic | Drawing out splinters & boils | Homeopathic 18g | Amazon |
| Hyland’s Pride Drawing Salve | Homeopathic | Gentle, all-natural relief | Homeopathic 18g | Amazon |
| MG217 Ichthammol Drawing Salve | Drawing Salve | Budget-friendly daily drawer | Ichthammol 10% | Amazon |
| Quret Drawing Salve | Drawing Salve | Classic, trusted formula | Ichthammol 10% | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Boil Ease Pain Relieving Ointment
When the pain of an active boil is keeping you from functioning, this is the product to reach for. Boil Ease delivers a potent 20% Benzocaine solution, which is the maximum over-the-counter concentration for topical pain relief. That high percentage directly targets the nerve endings around the boil, providing a numbing effect that can last for hours rather than minutes. The two-pack format ensures you have a spare tube ready for the next flare-up, which is a practical consideration given how unpredictable boils can be.
The creamy texture is a deliberate design choice. Thinner liquids run off the skin, especially if the area is oily or moist, but this ointment stays put on the affected spot. This allows the Benzocaine to maintain constant contact with the skin, delivering consistent relief. It is designed specifically for the temporary relief of pain and discomfort caused by boils, not as a general-purpose first-aid cream, which makes it a targeted tool for this specific problem.
For external use only, this ointment is best applied once the boil has surfaced. It will not draw the boil out, but it will make the waiting period dramatically more bearable. If you have a boil that is already painful and visible, skipping the salves and going straight for this numbing agent is the more efficient route to immediate comfort.
Why it’s great
- Maximum-strength Benzocaine 20% provides fast, targeted numbing.
- Two tubes in one pack offer excellent value for recurring issues.
- Creamy consistency stays on the boil without running off.
Good to know
- Does not draw out the core of the boil; pain relief only.
- Not suitable for un-ruptured, deep boils.
2. Smile’s Prid Homeopathic Drawing Salve
Smile’s Prid has been a household name for generations, and its homeopathic formula is designed to gently draw out foreign objects like splinters, thorns, and the core of a boil. This two-pack contains two 18g containers, which is a generous amount for a product that is typically applied sparingly. The homeopathic approach uses highly diluted natural ingredients, making it a go-to for users who want to avoid strong chemicals or medicated solutions on their skin.
The smooth consistency of this salve makes it easy to apply a thick, targeted layer directly over the boil. Covering it with a bandage after application is recommended to enhance the drawing action and keep the salve from drying out. Users consistently report that this product works best when applied consistently over a few days, encouraging the boil to surface naturally rather than forcing it. It is also versatile enough for minor cuts, scratches, and redness, giving it a broader use case than single-purpose medicated ointments.
Because this is a homeopathic remedy, it works more slowly than a medicated drawing salve like MG217. Patience is key. However, for those with sensitive skin or a preference for natural formulations, this is the most reliable choice on the list. The compact size of each tin also makes it easy to toss into a travel bag or pocket for on-the-go treatment.
Why it’s great
- Natural homeopathic formula is gentle on sensitive skin.
- Two 18g containers offer plenty of product for multiple uses.
- Versatile for splinters, boils, and minor skin irritations.
Good to know
- Works slower than medicated alternatives; requires consistent use.
- Not effective for immediate pain relief.
3. MG217 10% Ichthammol Drawing Salve
MG217 delivers a classic 10% Ichthammol formulation — the gold-standard active ingredient for drawing salves. Ichthammol is a sulfonated shale oil that works by increasing blood flow to the application area, which helps the body push pus and infection to the surface. At 10%, this is the same concentration used in many hospital and clinic settings for managing minor abscesses and embedded foreign objects. The 1 oz tube is small but lasts a long time because you only need a pea-sized amount per application.
This salve is particularly effective for deep boils that have not yet come to a head. Applying a generous dollop and covering it with a bandage overnight often results in the boil surfacing within 24 to 48 hours. Unlike homeopathic options, this is a medicated product with a direct physiological effect, making it a faster choice for those who want results quickly. It is also made in the USA, which adds a layer of quality assurance for users concerned about manufacturing standards.
The main trade-off is that Ichthammol has a distinct, medicinal tar-like smell that some users find off-putting. It fades after a few minutes, but the initial application can be noticeable. It is also not designed for pain relief — you will still feel the throb until the boil drains. For drawing power at a budget-friendly price point, MG217 is hard to beat.
Why it’s great
- Standard 10% Ichthammol concentration provides reliable drawing action.
- Fast results — often brings a boil to a head in 24-48 hours.
- Made in the USA with dependable quality.
Good to know
- Has a noticeable medicinal tar smell upon application.
- No numbing agents for active pain relief.
4. Hyland’s Homeopathic Pride Drawing Salve
Hyland’s Pride is another heavyweight in the homeopathic drawing salve category, and it has been a trusted staple since 2006. This twin-pack provides two 18g containers, matching the quantity of Smile’s Prid at a slightly higher price point. The formula is designed to relieve symptoms of minor skin irritations, boils, superficial cuts, scratches, wounds, and redness. It is a true all-purpose drawing salve that can handle more than just boils, making it a versatile addition to any first-aid kit.
The key difference between Hyland’s Pride and Smile’s Prid comes down to brand heritage and slightly different homeopathic ingredient blends. Users who prefer the Hyland’s brand often cite its long-standing reputation in homeopathy. The application method is identical — apply a thick layer, cover with a bandage, and let it work overnight. It is particularly effective for raising splinters and encouraging boils to drain naturally without the need for lancing.
Like all homeopathic remedies, it requires patience and consistent application. It will not provide immediate relief from the throbbing pain of a boil, and it is not a substitute for a medicated pain reliever. However, for users committed to a natural approach, Hyland’s Pride offers a reliable, gentle solution that supports the body’s own healing processes without chemical intervention.
Why it’s great
- Trusted homeopathic brand with a long history of reliability.
- Versatile for boils, splinters, cuts, and minor skin issues.
- Two-pack format ensures you always have a spare.
Good to know
- Slightly more expensive than competing homeopathic brands.
- Does not provide fast pain relief on its own.
5. Quret Drawing Salve
Quret Drawing Salve has been a first-aid kit staple since 1918, and its longevity in the market speaks to its consistent performance. This 1 oz tube contains a classic Ichthammol-based formula that is effective for drawing out splinters, slivers, and relieving the itch from bug bites. While the product labeling primarily emphasizes splinter removal, the same drawing action applies to boils, making it a functional option for treating them.
The formulation is straightforward and no-nonsense, without any added pain relievers or unnecessary ingredients. This makes it a good choice for users who want a simple, dedicated drawing salve without paying for features they do not need. It is made in the USA and comes in a compact tube that fits easily into a glove box or a small first-aid pouch. The price point is very accessible, making it an easy purchase for those who want to stock up without a major investment.
The trade-offs are that the tube is smaller than some competitors, and it is primarily marketed as a splinter remover, which may cause some buyers to overlook its boil-drawing capabilities. It also lacks the numbing effect of Boil Ease or the natural appeal of the homeopathic options.
Why it’s great
- Proven Ichthammol formula with over 100 years of use.
- Compact and portable for travel or on-the-go first aid.
- Budget-friendly entry point for a dedicated drawing salve.
Good to know
- Smaller tube size may require more frequent repurchasing.
- Primarily marketed for splinters, not specifically for boils.
FAQ
Can I use a drawing salve on a boil that has already burst?
How long should I leave a drawing salve on a boil?
Is Benzocaine ointment safe to use on boils near the eyes or mouth?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best boil remedy winner is the Boil Ease Pain Relieving Ointment because it directly addresses the most pressing symptom—pain—with a maximum-strength Benzocaine formulation that works within minutes. If you need a natural drawing salve to encourage a deep boil to surface, grab the Smile’s Prid Homeopathic Drawing Salve. And for an effective, medicated drawing action without the high price tag, nothing beats the MG217 10% Ichthammol Drawing Salve.