A crayon eyeliner pencil should deliver a dense, creamy pigment in one effortless swipe without tugging your delicate lash line. The real challenge is finding a formula that stays locked in place for a full day of wear, resists humidity and tears, and doesn’t flake or fade into a creased mess by lunchtime.
I’m Mohammad — the founder and writer behind ProteinJug. I’ve spent thousands of hours analyzing user reviews and cosmetic chemistry specs to understand what separates a long-wearing, waterproof gel formulation from a chalky, smudge-prone pencil.
From drugstore staples to premium sticks with built-in sharpeners, I’ve curated the top performers that strike the best balance between pigment payoff, lasting power, and lash-line comfort. Find your perfect match with this curated list of the best crayon eyeliner pencil options for every makeup bag.
How To Choose The Best Crayon Eyeliner Pencil
Not all crayon liners are built the same. Some are meant for tightlining the upper waterline, while others blend out into a soft smoky eye. The key is matching the formula type to your specific eyeliner technique and skin chemistry.
Formula Type: Kohl vs. Cream Gel
Traditional kohl pencils deliver an intense, matte pigment that blends well, but they often shift on oily lids. Cream-gel hybrids offer a sturdier, waterproof film that locks down after several seconds. If you need all-day wear on the waterline, a gel-based stick is your safest bet.
Pigment Density and Glide
A superior crayon should deposit a fully opaque line in one pass without dragging. Dry, waxy pencils cause skipped application and require multiple layers. Look for descriptions that promise a “creamy glide” and “high-impact” saturation to avoid wasted effort at the lash line.
Waterproof and Smudge-Proof Performance
The difference between a so-called waterproof liner and a truly budge-proof one comes down to the film-forming polymers in the base. The best options in this category withstand tears, sweat, and humidity for 12 to 24 hours without migrating into fine lines or the outer corner of the eye.
Application Format: Retractable vs. Sharpenable
Retractable twist-up pencils offer a precise, self-sharpening tip that stays pointy with each twist. Traditional sharpenable pencils are often softer and better for smudging, but they risk tip breakage and require a sharpener. Choose based on your speed preference and desire for precision.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick | Premium Cream Stick | All-day wear, sensitive eyes | 24-hour waterproof wear | Amazon |
| tarte double take eyeliner | 2-in-1 Dual Ended | Waterline precision + winged liner | Waterproof gel pencil + liquid | Amazon |
| Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner | Professional Gel Pencil | Intense matte black definition | 24-hour waterproof gel formula | Amazon |
| Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal | Sparkle Kohl | Humidity & heat resistance | Withstands tears, sweat, rubbing | Amazon |
| Rimmel London Ultimate Kohl Kajal | Natural-Infused Kajal | Nourishing formula, affordable | Aloe vera + vitamin E, 24-hour wear | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick
Bobbi Brown’s Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick sets the standard for a true waterproof, non-creasing crayon formula. The creamy texture glides across the lash line without tugging or pulling, and it dries down to a flexible film that stays put for a full 24 hours. The fine-tip design allows for precise, sharp definition, and a quick smudge with a brush transforms the line into a soft, smokey eye. Users consistently report zero flaking, crumbling, or migration into fine lines, even after long days in variable conditions.
This stick is available in pigment-rich shades, including the popular Rich Chocolate, a neutral brown that flatters a wide range of skin tones. The built-in sharpener in the cap is a thoughtful touch that keeps the tip precise without needing a separate tool. Many users who previously relied on high-end brands like Clinique or Lancôme found this formula to be superior in every aspect — smoother application, longer wear, and no raccoon eye effect by the end of the day.
The only trade-off is the premium price point, which sits above most drugstore options. However, the chunky pencil format lasts longer than average twist-up liners, and the blendable, life-proof performance justifies the expense for those who demand durable, high-impact eye definition. For anyone who wears liner daily and struggles with smudging, this stick is a worthy investment.
Why it’s great
- True 24-hour waterproof wear without flaking or creasing.
- Ultra-creamy blendable formula for both precise lines and smokey looks.
- Built-in sharpener adds convenience for daily use.
Good to know
- Priced higher than most drugstore eyeliner pencils.
- Limited shade range compared to some competitors.
2. tarte double take eyeliner
Tarte’s double take eyeliner combines a semi-matte gel crayon on one end with a fine-point liquid pen on the other, giving you two complete eyeliner tools in one tube. The gel crayon side delivers a creamy, waterproof line that sets quickly without smudging, making it ideal for tightlining and defining the upper waterline. The liquid side offers a flexible brush tip for sharp wings and detailed flicks. Users report the gel side holds up for over 12 hours in punishing weather conditions — from below-freezing NYC wind to humid environments — without fading or running.
The formula is vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with clean beauty standards, and the lightweight texture doesn’t weigh down the lid. Both ends produce an intense black matte finish that stays true from morning to night. The dual-ended format makes this a particularly strong value for travelers or those who like to switch between pencil and liquid looks without carrying extra products. Reviews consistently note that the gel side outperforms many standalone gel pencils in terms of staying power.
On the downside, a small percentage of users report that the liquid side can irritate sensitive eyes or cause a metallic taste in the mouth after application. For those who only use the gel side, the liquid end ends up wasted. However, if both formats work for your eye chemistry, this two-in-one is one of the most versatile options in the mid-range price tier.
Why it’s great
- Two distinct eyeliner formats in one convenient package.
- Gel side delivers exceptional all-day waterproof hold.
- Vegan and cruelty-free formula.
Good to know
- Liquid side can irritate very sensitive eyes.
- Both ends must be used to avoid product waste.
3. Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner
Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner is built for those who prioritize maximum pigment density and a flawless matte black finish. The gel formula glides on with an ultra-creamy texture that deposits a fully opaque line on the first pass, without any skip or drag. It sets into a waterproof, smudge-proof film that lasts a full day, even on the waterline. Users report that it stays intact through long workdays and evening events without requiring touch-ups, and it removes cleanly with a standard oil-based makeup remover.
The retractable twist-up design is a standout feature for precision and convenience. Each twist delivers a fresh, sharp point that maintains control for tightlining and sharp wings. The pencil never requires sharpening, eliminating the risk of a broken tip mid-application. The pigment is so dense that a single swipe is sufficient for a bold look, and the formula allows for a few seconds of blending time before it locks in place, making it versatile for both precise definition and smoked-out eyes.
A few users note that the price feels slightly elevated compared to other gel pencils with similar performance, and some find the formula slightly less creamy than kohl alternatives. However, for professional-grade intensity and reliable all-day wear, the ABH Darkside Gel Liner is a top-tier choice that consistently outperforms drugstore options in both longevity and pigmentation.
Why it’s great
- Exceptional one-swipe pigment density for bold black lines.
- Retractable twist-up prevents tip breakage and sharpener mess.
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear.
Good to know
- Retail price is higher than many comparable drugstore pencils.
- Texture is less creamy than traditional kohl for heavy smudgers.
4. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Eyeliner, Pack of 2
Rimmel’s Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal is a cult favorite for a reason: it delivers a soft, smudge-able kohl finish with a subtle sparkle that brightens the eyes without overpowering. The formula is specifically engineered to withstand tears, sweat, and humidity, making it a go-to for hot climates or emotional days. Users in Texas heat report the liner survives 12+ hours without fading or smudging, even on the lower lash line. The glittery finish stays intact throughout the day, adding a dimensional sheen that doesn’t migrate.
This pack of two offers strong value for a mid-range price, and each pencil can be sharpened to a fine point for precise application. The core is soft and glides easily without tugging, and the pigmentation is buildable — one swipe gives a sheer sparkle effect, while layering intensifies the color. Many users who struggled to find a glitter eyeliner that doesn’t flake found this one to be the perfect replacement for a discontinued drugstore sparkle pencil. The smudgy texture also makes it ideal for creating a soft, lived-in smoky eye.
The downside is the soft core: it can break or crumble during sharpening if not handled gently. Users who prefer a traditional twist-up retractable format may find the need for a sharpener inconvenient. Additionally, the color is more of a dark grey-black with sparkle rather than a true saturated black, so those seeking pure matte intensity should look elsewhere. For a durable, humid-proof sparkle liner at a reasonable price, this two-pack is hard to beat.
Why it’s great
- Proven humidity and sweat resistance for 12+ hours.
- Subtle sparkle finish adds dimension to everyday looks.
- Excellent value for a two-pack of reliable kohl pencils.
Good to know
- Soft core can break during sharpening if not careful.
- Not a true matte black; has a grey-black undertone with shimmer.
5. Rimmel London Ultimate Kohl Kajal Waterproof Eyeliner
Rimmel London’s Ultimate Kohl Kajal proves that a budget-friendly crayon liner can still deliver impressive performance. The formula is enriched with aloe vera and vitamin E, which nourish the delicate skin around the eyes while providing a lightweight, comfortable wear. It applies smoothly with a single stroke and sets into a waterproof film that lasts up to 24 hours. Users with sensitive eyes report no irritation, and the product’s versatility as both an eyeliner and an eyeshadow base adds to its appeal.
The Black Obsidian shade is one of the blackest kohl eyeliners in the drugstore aisle, offering deep saturation without needing multiple passes. It works well for tightlining the upper waterline and can be blended out quickly with a brush or finger for a smoky effect. Many reviewers have made this their holy grail liner, citing its staying power and rich color payoff as reasons they stick with it year after year. The sharpenable design allows for a precise point, though some users note the tip can be fragile straight out of the package.
A few customers experienced smudging on very oily lids, and the need for a sharpener is a minor inconvenience for those who prefer retractable pencils. The tube packaging is minimalist, and the liner’s soft texture means it can wear down faster than harder pencils. Nevertheless, for an entry-level price point, this Rimmel liner delivers a level of pigment and longevity that rivals many mid-range competitors, making it an excellent starting point for anyone new to crayon-style eyeliner.
Why it’s great
- Deepest kohl black in the drugstore category for dramatic definition.
- Aloe vera and vitamin E soothe the sensitive eye area.
- Waterproof and long-wearing for up to 24 hours.
Good to know
- May smudge on very oily lids over extended wear.
- Requires a separate sharpener; tip can break if not careful.
FAQ
Does a crayon eyeliner pencil work on the waterline?
How can I sharpen a crayon eyeliner pencil without breaking the tip?
Is a retractable eyeliner pencil better than a sharpenable one?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best crayon eyeliner pencil winner is the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick because it combines a creamy, blendable texture with true 24-hour waterproof wear and a built-in sharpener. If you want the versatility of two complete eyeliner formats in one tube, grab the tarte double take eyeliner. And for a budget-friendly kohl pencil that delivers deep pigment and natural ingredients without irritating sensitive eyes, nothing beats the Rimmel London Ultimate Kohl Kajal.