Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.5 Best Low Fat Mayo | Half the Fat, Full Flavor That Works

Check Price on Amazon

Hellmann’s Light hits the exact balance that most light mayos miss: it tastes like the real thing. The 60% fat and calorie reduction is impressive on paper, but what matters at the table is that it doesn’t taste watery or artificially sweetened. The inclusion of 230mg of ALA Omega-3 per serving is a bonus you won’t find in most competitors, making this a smarter choice for heart-conscious eaters. Made with 100% cage-free eggs and a simple oil-and-vinegar base, the ingredient list is clean enough for everyday use. Multiple reviewers confirmed the flavor is identical to the full-fat version, which is the highest compliment a light mayo can receive.

The three 30-ounce jars give you plenty of volume for a household that goes through mayo quickly, whether you’re making potato salad, tuna sandwiches, or a quick burger spread. The packaging is the only recurring complaint—some jars arrived dented or with compromised seals because the box lacked adequate internal cushioning. If you’re ordering, it’s worth checking the “Use By” date immediately upon arrival, as a few customers noted dates as close as two months out. For the volume and the flavor, this remains the most reliable everyday low-fat mayo on the market.

Reviewers who have used Hellmann’s for decades reported that the light version holds up in baking and as a base for dressings and dips without separating. The only practical downside is that once opened, the jar format requires a clean utensil every time to avoid introducing crumbs or bacteria. If you’re willing to accept that minor inconvenience, this is the set to stock your fridge with.

Check Price on Amazon

Blue Plate Light is the closest you can get to a homemade texture in a reduced-fat bottle. The secret is a higher proportion of egg yolks compared to most commercial mayos, which gives it a creamier, almost custard-like body. It has only half the calories and fat of regular Blue Plate, but the mouthfeel is so rich that you won’t feel like you are missing anything. Real Southerners swear by this brand—it won accolades from Epicurious, Southern Living, and Cook’s Illustrated, and the light version holds that reputation well in blind taste tests.

This six-pack of 30-ounce jars is a bulk buy intended for large families or serious meal preppers. The ingredient list is refreshingly simple: oil, vinegar, egg yolks, and a few stabilizers. There is no artificial aftertaste, and the sugar content is lower than many competitors, which keeps the flavor savory rather than sweet. A few customers noted that the squeeze bottle version (sold separately) has trouble getting the last bit out, but the jar format eliminates that issue entirely. If you store the jars in a cool pantry, they stay stable until opening, and the wide mouth makes it easy to scrape every last bit.

The main consideration is that Blue Plate is not available in every local grocery store outside the South, so for many people, this bulk order is the only way to get it. Shipping is generally reliable, though one reviewer mentioned that heat during transit can cause separation—just stir it back together. If you prioritize a thick, egg-forward spread that elevates a simple turkey sandwich into something special, this is the light mayo to buy.

Check Price on Amazon

Duke’s Light Olive Oil mayo is the go-to for anyone who wants the health halo of olive oil without sacrificing the tangy punch Duke’s is known for. The olive oil base gives it a noticeably richer, fruitier flavor than standard soybean oil mayos, and it pairs beautifully with Mediterranean-style wraps, grilled chicken salads, and roasted vegetables. It has half the fat and calories of regular Duke’s, but the texture stays surprisingly lush—reviewers consistently use words like “creamy” and “delicious” without qualification.

The three 11.5-ounce squeeze bottles are ideal for smaller households or for people who want to reduce waste by using every drop (though the squeeze design does leave some product trapped at the bottom). The flavor has no chemical aftertaste, which is a rare achievement for a light mayo. Many customers reported switching entirely to Duke’s after trying this version, citing the clean finish and versatility in recipes from deviled eggs to remoulade sauce. The squeeze bottle format also makes it easy to apply directly to bread or a bowl without dirtying a knife.

The primary drawback is the short shelf life once you open a bottle—customers recommend using it within a month for peak freshness. Additionally, the per-ounce cost is higher than buying a jar, and some users noted that the expiration dates on shipped units can be alarmingly close (under 30 days). If you commit to using it quickly and don’t mind the premium price for a premium oil base, this light mayo delivers an unmatched flavor experience.

Check Price on Amazon

Hellmann’s Light in stick packet form is the ultimate solution for anyone who needs precise, no-mess portions. Each 0.38-ounce packet contains exactly 25 calories and delivers the same 60% reduced-fat recipe as the jar version, making it ideal for calorie counters who weigh every ingredient. The convenience factor is enormous: toss a few packets in your lunch bag, keep them in your desk drawer, or pack them for travel without worrying about refrigeration until opened.

The taste is slightly different from the jar—a few reviewers noticed an 8/10 similarity—likely due to the packaging materials, but it is still a full, creamy mayonnaise that works great on sandwiches, tuna packs, and wraps. The easy-open rip tab is genuinely functional, and the portion size is just right for 1–2 sandwiches depending on how generously you spread. This bulk box of 210 packets is a restaurant-grade purchase that will last a single person several months if used daily.

The main issue is mechanical: some packets arrived with manufacturing defects, such as a cut in the middle that caused grease to leak, reducing the usable count slightly. Also, the per-packet cost is significantly higher than buying a jar, so this only makes financial sense if you absolutely need the portion control. For meal prep, packed lunches, and on-the-go use, the convenience outweighs the premium price.

Check Price on Amazon

Kraft Light Mayo packets are the pragmatic choice for anyone who hates wasting condiments or simply doesn’t have fridge space for a full jar. Each 0.44‑ounce packet is slightly larger than Hellmann’s offering, giving you a bit more spread per serving. The light recipe cuts the fat and calories roughly in half compared to full-fat Kraft mayo, and the flavor is what you’d expect from a national brand—consistent, mildly tangy, and perfectly fine for sandwiches, subs, or mixing into canned tuna.

The real strength here is the form factor. People with tiny apartment fridges, dorm rooms, or RVs use these packets as a shelf-stable solution that doesn’t need refrigeration until opened. Reviewers specifically mentioned keeping them in a glove compartment or desk drawer for emergency lunch stops. The 200-count box is heavy (over 6 pounds), so this is a buy‑once, forget‑it investment that will cover you for months. The packets are also branded, which makes them a clean option for bag lunches or office kitchens.

On the downside, the Kraft light recipe is slightly thinner than Hellmann’s or Blue Plate, so don’t expect the same level of cling on thick bread. A few customers also noted that the individual packets create more plastic waste than a single jar, which matters if you are trying to reduce your environmental footprint. That said, for pure logistics and zero-waste-in-the-fridge convenience, Kraft Light packets are hard to beat.