Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.7 Best Formula For Colic And Gassy Babies | Calm Tummies

Check Price on Amazon

The Enfamil NeuroPro Gentlease is the benchmark that other gentle formulas measure themselves against. Its key mechanism is partial protein hydrolysis—the proteins are broken down into smaller fragments that are significantly easier for a newborn’s digestive tract to manage. This process directly targets the fermentation and gas buildup that cause colicky crying, typically showing a reduction in fussiness and spit-up within 24 hours.

Beyond digestion, this formula includes a patented prebiotic blend of PDX and GOS, which promotes softer, more regular stools—a critical detail for babies who strain or cry during bowel movements. The DHA and choline content supports brain development, and the HuMO6 immune blend provides vitamins and minerals that mimic some components found in breast milk. The 78-ounce 4-pack gives you a two to three week supply depending on feeding volume.

Parents consistently report that this formula works for babies who were born small or had particularly sensitive bellies from day one. The one recurring note is that the powder can cake inside Baby Brezza machines, so manual mixing with warm water yields the most consistent texture. For a first-line intervention that balances gentle digestion with complete nutrition, this is the formula to try first.

Check Price on Amazon

When a baby has a confirmed cow’s milk protein allergy (CMPA), partial hydrolysis isn’t enough—the immune system still recognizes those protein fragments as threats. Similac Alimentum uses extensive hydrolysis, breaking casein proteins down so thoroughly that the body no longer mounts an allergic response. This is the formula that stops colic caused by true protein sensitivity, and the manufacturer claims relief within 24 hours in most infants.

Alimentum is the first and only hypoallergenic formula to include 2’-FL HMO, an immune-nourishing prebiotic that supports gut flora diversity. The formula also contains DHA for brain development, and it can be purchased with SNAP benefits in eligible states. Parents report that the switch from standard formula to Alimentum resolved constipation, vomiting, and the constant arching and screaming within two days, though some babies do produce darker, iron-smelling stool as a side effect of the hydrolyzed protein and iron content.

The trade-off is the bitter taste common to extensively hydrolyzed formulas—some babies may initially refuse it, though most accept it after a brief transition period. For parents whose babies have been formally diagnosed with CMPA, this is the most effective over-the-counter option available, and the price is competitive compared to prescription alternatives.

Check Price on Amazon

Bobbie’s Gentle formula stands out because it retains 100% lactose as the sole carbohydrate source while still using smaller, hydrolyzed milk proteins for easier digestion. Most gentle formulas swap lactose for corn syrup solids or maltodextrin to reduce gas, but Bobbie’s approach is to replicate breast milk’s carbohydrate profile—lactose is the primary sugar in human milk, and many parents prefer to keep it in the diet if the baby tolerates it.

The formula is USDA Organic and Clean Label Project Certified, which means it undergoes rigorous 2,000+ quality checks per batch. The ingredient list is short: organic lactose, organic skim milk, organic high-oleic oils, and vitamins. No corn syrup, no maltodextrin, no sucrose. For babies who are fussy but not truly lactose intolerant, this formula often results in less spit-up and more predictable bowel movements compared to organic formulas with standard intact proteins.

The packaging can be slightly confusing because the Gentle version looks almost identical to Bobbie’s standard Organic formula, so check the label carefully. Some parents also note that their babies produce more flatulence and greener, smellier stool on this formula—this is actually a sign that the digestive system is processing the lactose normally, but it can be alarming if you aren’t expecting it.

Check Price on Amazon

Dr. Brown’s Soothe Pro is built around a single ingredient that sets it apart: the probiotic strain Lactobacillus reuteri, which has been clinically demonstrated to reduce crying time in colicky infants. The formulation uses 100% whey protein (no casein), which means no curdling in the stomach and a faster transit time—ideal for babies who spit up or seem uncomfortable immediately after feeding.

The two-step hydrolysis process used here makes the proteins 10 times smaller than intact cow’s milk proteins, placing this firmly in the partially hydrolyzed category but with a stronger focus on probiotic-driven gut health. The can size at 30.6 ounces is one of the largest in this comparison, which means fewer reorders per month. The osmolality of this formula is also relatively low (207 at 20 kcal), which is gentler on a baby’s developing kidneys than some competitors.

One drawback is mixing: the powder tends to clump and create bubbles, so you’ll want to stir rather than shake aggressively to avoid extra air intake. Some users also note the formula lacks a built-in scoop leveling edge, which can lead to inconsistent measurements. For the specific problem of gas and colic linked to gut flora imbalance, this formula’s probiotic focus makes it a smart early choice.

Check Price on Amazon

Baby’s Only A2 Organic takes a completely different path from the hydrolyzed-protein crowd. Instead of predigesting the proteins, it sources milk from cows that produce only A2 beta-casein—a protein structure closer to human breast milk that doesn’t produce the same inflammatory response as standard A1 casein. For babies who don’t have a severe allergy but still react to conventional formula with gas and mucus in stool, A2 can stop the reaction without needing to switch to a hydrolyzed formula.

The formula is made in small batches at a state-of-the-art facility in Ohio, and it’s certified organic with no corn syrup, palm oil, GMOs, or artificial growth hormones. The proprietary organic fat blend includes organic high-oleic oils that mimic the fatty acid profile of breast milk. Parents often report that this formula is gentle enough for transition from breastfeeding, as it lacks the intense bitterness of hydrolyzed options.

One thing to note: this formula does not include added probiotics, so if your baby was born via C-section (and missed vaginal microbiome inoculation), you may want to add a separate probiotic supplement. It also has a lower availability on Amazon than the bigger brands, so setting up a subscription is wise to avoid stock shortages.

Check Price on Amazon

The Amazon Brand Mama Bear Gentle formula is a direct analog to Enfamil Gentlease, with the same partially hydrolyzed protein structure and a 2’-FL HMO inclusion that you’d expect from a premium brand. The protein breakdown targets the same gas and fussiness problems, and parents who switch from the name brand consistently report no difference in their baby’s digestion, stool quality, or acceptance of the bottle.

This formula is non-GMO, gluten-free, certified kosher, and free from artificial growth hormones. It contains DHA and choline for brain support, and the scoop storage integrated into the can keeps preparation clean. The consistency mixes smoothly without the clumping seen in some competitors, which is a notable advantage for overnight feeds when you’re half-asleep.

The main consideration is that this is a store brand, so it’s not sold in brick-and-mortar stores—you need Amazon delivery, and without a Prime subscription, shipping can be slower. But for parents who want the same gentlease-level protein hydrolysis and immune support at a significantly lower per-ounce cost, this is the most practical option in the category.

Check Price on Amazon

PurAmino is the absolute last resort for babies who cannot tolerate even extensively hydrolyzed formulas. It’s composed entirely of free amino acids—the building blocks of protein—so the body absorbs them directly without needing to digest any intact or partially intact proteins. This formula exists for severe CMPA, multiple food protein allergies, FPIES, eosinophilic esophagitis, and short bowel syndrome.

The clinical results are dramatic: babies who were screaming, having bloody diapers, and failing to gain weight on other formulas often show complete resolution of symptoms within one week. Parents report that babies who previously refused every bottle eagerly drank PurAmino, and weight gain accelerated because the energy was no longer diverted to fighting an allergic reaction. It also contains DHA at expert-recommended levels for brain development.

The downsides are substantial: the price is the highest in the category, the cans are small (14.1 oz each), and the powder consistency can vary between batches—some runs come out stickier than others. Many families rely on insurance coverage or WIC to afford this, and a pediatrician’s prescription is often required. For the vast majority of gassy or colicky babies, this is overkill, but for the small subset with true multiple food protein allergies, it is life-changing.