An eyeliner that perfectly hugs the lash line without bleeding, flaking, or transferring onto your lower lid is the holy grail for any eye look. The delicate skin under your eyes and on the waterline demands a formula that glides on effortlessly, sets quickly, and refuses to budge through a long workday, a tear-jerker movie, or a humid commute. Finding that balance between rich pigment and eye-safe comfort separates a daily staple from a disappointing drawer filler.
I’m Mohammad — the founder and writer behind ProteinJug. I’ve spent years analyzing cosmetic ingredient lists, evaluating wear-test feedback, and comparing formula claims to real-world performance so you can skip the trial and error.
Whether you need a pencil for tightlining, a gel for sharp wings, or a kohl for smudgy definition, this guide narrows down the top performers so you can confidently choose your next best under eyeliner.
How To Choose The Best Under Eyeliner
Selecting the right eyeliner for your lower lash line and waterline comes down to three factors: formula chemistry, application method, and your specific eye sensitivity. Here’s what to look for before adding one to your cart.
Waterproof vs. Smudge-Proof — It’s Not the Same
A waterproof formula resists water but can still transfer if it’s oily, while a smudge-proof formula stays locked in place against friction and natural eye moisture. For the waterline, you need a product that is explicitly both — many liners labeled “waterproof” will still smudge under the lash line after an hour. Check multiple customer reviews for the phrase “no transfer” or “never smudged” to confirm real-world performance.
Retractable vs. Traditional Pencil
Retractable pencils eliminate sharpening and keep a consistent tip shape, which is essential for precise waterline application without poking. Traditional wooden pencils can dull quickly and require regular sharpening that sometimes breaks the core. If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, a retractable gel pencil is often the gentler choice because it glides with less pressure.
Ingredient Check for Sensitive Eyes
Look for nourishing ingredients like jojoba oil, vitamin E, chamomile, or avocado oil — these soothe and protect the delicate under-eye area. Avoid liners with heavy fragrances, parabens, or petroleum, which can cause irritation, watering, or smudging. Hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested labels are meaningful signals, but always read the ingredient list to confirm there’s no hidden irritant for your unique skin chemistry.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal | Kohl Pencil | Humidity and heat resistance | 16+ hour wear in extreme heat | Amazon |
| Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner | Gel Retractable | Sharp precision and matte black finish | 24-hour waterproof wear | Amazon |
| IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable | Retractable Gel | Sensitive eyes and hooded lids | Avocado oil & chamomile formula | Amazon |
| BaeBlu Natural Eyeliner Pencil | Organic Pencil | Daily natural makeup with minimal eye irritation | Hypoallergenic with jojoba & castor oil | Amazon |
| Radiant Professional Black Waterproof Pencil | Gel Pencil | Bold waterline color with a built-in smudger | Vitamin E & jojoba oil formula | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Eyeliner
This two-pack of Rimmel’s iconic kohl pencil has earned a cult following for a reason: it withstands tears, sweat, and rubbing without migrating from the waterline or lower lash line. The soft, creamy formula applies with zero tugging and dries down to a smudge-proof finish that holds for over 16 hours — verified by users working 12-hour shifts in humid environments like Florida and Texas warehouses. The subtle sparkle adds dimension without looking glittery on the under-eye area.
Because it is a traditional wood pencil, you will need to sharpen it regularly, and some users report the core can break if you over-sharpen or press too hard. The trade-off is a richly pigmented, blendable line that also works beautifully for smudging into a smoky eye before it fully sets. For anyone who prioritizes all-day wear in sweaty or humid conditions, this is the benchmark.
Customer feedback consistently mentions that it does not irritate sensitive eyes, and the two-pack value makes it easy to keep one in your desk and one in your makeup bag. The gel-like consistency creates a tight seal on the waterline that most liquid liners cannot match.
Why it’s great
- Lasts 16+ hours even in intense heat and humidity.
- Soft, creamy glide on the waterline without tugging.
- Subtle sparkle adds eye-brightening dimension.
Good to know
- Wood casing can break during sharpening if too much force is used.
- Not ideal for sharp, precise wings — designed for smudgy or lined looks.
2. Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner
Anastasia Beverly Hills delivers a professional-grade gel liner in a convenient retractable format with the Darkside shade. The formula is intensely matte black with full pigment from the first stroke — no layering needed for opacity. It is specifically engineered for 24-hour waterproof wear and has been ophthalmologist-tested, making it a reliable choice for tightlining and the waterline without running or fading.
The ultra-creamy glide means zero tugging on the delicate under-eye skin, and the twist-up mechanism keeps the tip sharp for precise application. Users with active lifestyles — including pickleball players — report it stays in place through sweat and movement without transferring to the lower lid. It is also versatile enough to smudge out for a smoky eye before it sets fully.
A few customers note that the formula feels slightly drier than some drugstore gel pencils, which can require a gentle hand during application. However, the trade-off is a budge-proof finish that rivals high-end department store liners. If matte black intensity and all-day staying power are non-negotiable, this is a top contender for your everyday rotation.
Why it’s great
- Intense, true matte black pigment that doesn’t fade.
- Retractable design maintains a sharp tip for tightlining.
- Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for the waterline.
Good to know
- Formula can feel slightly dry if you prefer a very creamy texture.
- Higher unit cost compared to drugstore pencils.
3. IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable Eyeliner
IT Cosmetics built this retractable pencil specifically for aging and sensitive eyes, and the “No-Tug” claim holds up in practice. The formula blends avocado oil, chamomile extract, vitamin E, and carnauba wax, creating a cushiony glide that requires almost no pressure — ideal for mature skin or anyone with hooded lids who has struggled with pulling and skipping. The rich color payoff rivals gel formulas without the dry drag.
Users with hooded eyes report zero transfer or smearing onto their crease throughout the day, thanks to the waterproof, budge-proof finish. The retractable mechanism means no sharpening, and the twist action keeps the tip consistently precise for a clean waterline application. It is gentle enough for contact lens wearers and does not sting even if you apply directly to the inner rim.
The only real downside is the small product volume — given the price point, you will likely use it faster than a traditional pencil. But for those who prioritize comfort, zero tugging, and a formula that stays put without irritation, this is a premium choice that justifies its cost with consistent daily performance.
Why it’s great
- Silky glide with no tugging, perfect for mature or hooded eyes.
- Formulated with avocado oil and chamomile for soothing wear.
- Stays transfer-free on the lower lash line all day.
Good to know
- Smaller amount of product per pencil for the price.
- Color range is limited compared to drugstore lines.
4. BaeBlu Natural Eyeliner Pencil
If you have experienced allergic reactions or eye infections from conventional eyeliners, BaeBlu’s natural pencil is a refreshing alternative. Formulated with organic jojoba and castor oils, it is free from parabens, petroleum, artificial colors, and fragrances. The pencil is hypoallergenic and vegan-certified, designed specifically for delicate skin that cannot tolerate chemical additives. Multiple users with a history of eye infections report zero irritation after switching to this brand.
The deep black color applies smoothly with a traditional pencil feel — not too soft, not too hard — and it stays put for most of the day. Some users note minor smudging after 8+ hours, but the trade-off is a nourishing formula that helps condition lashes and protect the skin barrier. It performs best for daily natural looks rather than 16-hour marathons or high-intensity workouts.
Because it is a wood pencil, you will need to sharpen it, and the core can sometimes break if the pencil is dropped. But for anyone who prioritizes organic ingredients and eye health above maximum wear time, this is a solid entry-level cleaner beauty option that still delivers rich color.
Why it’s great
- Hypoallergenic, vegan, and free from common irritants.
- Nourishes lashes with jojoba and castor oils during wear.
- Safe for users prone to eye infections or allergic reactions.
Good to know
- May smudge slightly after a full workday.
- Traditional pencil requires sharpening; core can break.
5. Radiant Professional Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Radiant Professional’s gel pencil comes with a built-in smudger on the cap, making it a handy tool for creating everything from a tight, defined line to a blown-out smoky effect. The formula is enriched with vitamin E and jojoba oil, so it glides smoothly across the waterline without dragging, despite being waterproof and smudge-proof. It is manufactured in Germany and is also gluten-free and cruelty-free.
Color payoff is deep and buildable, and the pencil performs well as a waterline liner that stays in place without fading for most of the day. A few users note that the color can fade after several hours compared to higher-end gel formulas, but the included smudger tool adds versatility that many pencils lack. It also doubles as a brow pencil for added definition, giving you more utility per pencil.
The main frustration reported by buyers is the packaging: the pencil comes in a sealed blister pack with a glued label that can be extremely difficult to open. Once you get past that hurdle, the performance for the price is solid, especially if you like switching between precise lining and smudged looks without needing multiple products.
Why it’s great
- Built-in smudger cap for quick smoky eye transitions.
- Smooth, creamy application with vitamin E and jojoba oil.
- Can double as a brow pencil for added versatility.
Good to know
- Packaging is difficult to open without tools.
- Color fades slightly by end of a long day.
FAQ
Can I use any eyeliner on my waterline or do I need a specific type?
Why does my under-eye liner always smudge by midday?
Are retractable pencils better than traditional wooden pencils for the under-eye area?
What ingredients should I avoid if I have sensitive eyes?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best under eyeliner winner is the Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal because it delivers exceptional heat and humidity resistance without breaking the bank, and the two-pack makes it easy to stock up. If you want intensive matte black precision and 24-hour wear, grab the Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner. And for sensitive eyes that need a tug-free, nourishing formula, nothing beats the IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable Eyeliner.