A good eyeliner pencil is the difference between a sharp, defined eye look and a smudged mess by lunch. The right one glides across the lash line without tugging, delivers intense pigment in a single pass, and stays put through humidity, tears, and long days without becoming a raccoon-eye liability.
I’m Mohammad — the founder and writer behind ProteinJug. I’ve spent years analyzing the chemical formulations and real-world performance data of hundreds of eyeliners to understand which ingredients and delivery systems actually prevent smudging and fading over extended wear.
Whether you want a creamy gel pencil for the waterline or a precise retractable liner for sharp wings, this guide cuts through the hype to recommend only the most reliable options. These are the best rated eyeliner pencil choices for people who need performance that lasts from morning to night.
How To Choose The Best Rated Eyeliner Pencil
Not every eyeliner pencil can survive the waterline, oily lids, or a 12-hour workday. The difference between a liner you love and one you toss after a week comes down to three variables: formula type, delivery mechanism, and the quality of the pigment load. Here is what matters most when sorting through the options.
Formula Type: Gel, Kohl, or Wax-Based
Gel liners dominate the upper tier because of their creamy texture and waterproof film-forming polymers. They glide on smoothly, set quickly, and resist transfer. Kohl pencils offer a softer look with blend ability but trade staying power — better for smoky eyes than defined wings. Traditional wax-based pencil formulas lock in pigment but often require more drag during application, which can irritate the lash line if the core is too dry.
Pencil Delivery: Retractable vs. Sharpenable
Retractable pencils eliminate the need for a sharpener and maintain a consistent tip shape, which is critical for tightlining and precise application along the waterline. Sharpenable pencils typically hold a richer, softer core that performs better for gel textures, but you lose product to the sharpener and risk breaking the tip if the formula is delicate. For daily convenience and hygiene, retractable designs are the clear choice.
Waterproof and Wear Time Claims
Not all “waterproof” claims are equal. Formulas that rely on waxes and silicones resist water better than those built with water-soluble thickeners. Look for pencils that advertise 24-hour wear or are ophthalmologist tested, especially if you plan to wear them on the waterline. The best performers combine a strong film former with a quick-dry mechanism that locks the pigment onto the skin before it can settle into fine lines.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner | Gel Pencil | Intense matte black definition | 24-hour waterproof | Amazon |
| Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! | Retractable | All-day waterline comfort | 24-hour wear, smudge-proof | Amazon |
| IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable | Retractable | Mature and sensitive eyes | Avocado oil + chamomile | Amazon |
| Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner | Gel Pencil | Graphic and smoky eye looks | 24-hour waterproof | Amazon |
| tarte double take eyeliner | 2-in-1 | Travel and dual-look versatility | Waterproof + vegan | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner
The Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner delivers the most intense, saturated matte black payoff of any pencil on this list. Its gel formula glides on without tugging or skipping, then sets into a waterproof film that survives sweat, tears, and humidity. Users report it stays intact through active sessions like pickleball without fading or running, which is rare for a cream-based pencil.
The retractable twist-up mechanism maintains a sharp point for precise tightlining and wing creation, and the formula stays wet for a few seconds — long enough to smoke out the line before it locks in place. At 0.01 ounces, the product size is standard for the premium pencil category, but the pigment concentration means you need less product per application than mass-market alternatives.
The main drawback is the price relative to drugstore options — some users find the cost hard to justify when cheaper liners perform acceptably for standard wear. Additionally, a small number of reviewers noted the tip can feel slightly dry depending on how long the pencil has been stored, so check the freshness date before purchasing.
Why it’s great
- True matte black pigment that looks jet-black even on the waterline
- 24-hour waterproof performance that lasts through exercise and humidity
- Smooth gel glide that doesn’t skip or pull at the lash line
Good to know
- More expensive than comparable drugstore gel pencils
- Some units can arrive with a slightly dry tip due to shelf storage
2. Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! 24 Hour Eye Pencil
The Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! pencil earns its reputation as a waterline specialist — it glides onto the inner rim without dragging and stays put without migrating into the eye. The formula is water-resistant but not stiff, so it won’t break when sharpened or twist up unevenly. Reviews consistently note it avoids the raccoon-eye effect that plagues softer kohl pencils.
The dual-ended design includes a liner tip on one side and a smudging tool on the other, giving you the flexibility to define a crisp line or soften it into a smoky look. Users with sensitive eyes report no irritation during waterline application, and the pigment stays opaque even after 12 hours of wear. The matte finish reads as a classic black without any glossy sheen.
On the downside, the pencil’s smaller diameter means it twists up quickly, and some users feel it runs out faster than standard pencil formulations. The price sits firmly in the premium range, making it a recurring cost for daily wearers. For occasional use, however, the performance per application holds up well against more expensive competitors.
Why it’s great
- Stays on the waterline without irritation or smudging
- Dual-ended smudger tool for versatile looks
- Smooth, non-drag formula suitable for sensitive eyes
Good to know
- Smaller pencil size runs out faster than larger formats
- Premium price per ounce compared to drugstore options
3. IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable Eyeliner
The IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Eyeliner is formulated specifically for mature, hooded, and sensitive eyes where tugging causes irritation or disrupted application. Its core includes avocado oil, chamomile extract, vitamin E, and carnauba wax — ingredients that condition the lash line while delivering pigment. User reports from people with 60-year-old skin confirm it glides on without skip or drag.
The retractable mechanism is engineered for zero-fuss application — no sharpening needed, and the tip stays clean between uses. The formula is waterproof without being cement-like, so it adheres to the lash line without fading or transferring onto the crease of hooded eyes. Color payoff is rich, though not as jet-black as the Anastasia option — it reads as an intense charcoal-black that works well for both daytime definition and evening looks.
The product dimensions are compact, which makes it travel-friendly, but some users note the pigment fades slightly faster on the waterline compared to gel-based competitors. The price point is the highest of the mid-range tier, and while the conditioning ingredients justify the cost for sensitive users, those without eye irritation may find equal performance in more affordable alternatives.
Why it’s great
- Conditioning ingredients allow tug-free application on mature or sensitive eyes
- Waterproof formula stays put on hooded eyes without transfer
- Retractable design eliminates sharpener waste and travel mess
Good to know
- Pigment depth is slightly less intense than pure gel pencils
- Higher cost per ounce than liners without conditioning additives
4. Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner
The Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner is the buildable champion for creative eye looks. The pigment-rich gel formula stays wet for a few seconds after application, allowing you to blend or smoke it out before it sets into a waterproof, 24-hour finish. Users describe it as the only pencil that remains visible after a full day of wear without migration or fading, even on oily lids.
The sharpenable pencil format holds a softer gel core than retractable designs, which gives you more product control during application. The color range extends beyond black to a rich brown that suits blondes and lighter eye colors with a natural definition. Reviews from long-term users (some since 2015) cite its reliability as the go-to for both daily wear and special occasions.
The main issue is the sharpenable design — users report the tip breaks frequently during sharpening, especially with standard cosmetic sharpeners. Switching to the brand’s Always Sharp version avoids this problem, but that variant costs more. Additionally, the creamy formula can sometimes feel too soft in warm climates, leading to minor smudging on the outer corner during high humidity.
Why it’s great
- Stays wet for a few seconds, enabling blendable smoky eye looks
- Rich brown option provides natural definition for fair or blonde features
- 24-hour waterproof performance outperforms buildable formulas
Good to know
- Tip breaks easily during sharpening with standard sharpeners
- Soft gel formula can smudge slightly in high heat or humidity
5. tarte double take eyeliner
The tarte double take eyeliner solves the problem of needing two separate products for a single look. The gel pencil end delivers a semi-matte, smudge-proof line for the upper lash line, while the liquid felt-tip end allows for precise wing shaping or defining the outer corner. Users who tested it through brutal NYC winter conditions — below-freezing temperatures, rain, and wind — report it survives 12+ hours without transferring or fading.
The vegan and cruelty-free formula appeals to clean beauty shoppers without sacrificing performance. The gel side applies with a lightweight, creamy consistency that doesn’t drag, and the pigment load is dense enough to look opaque in one pass. The compact tube packaging is slim enough to fit in a clutch, making it a solid choice for on-the-go application or travel.
Multiple users report that the liquid side causes eye irritation or a metallic taste in the mouth after application, likely due to the liquid formula’s volatile components. If you have sensitive eyes, you may need to limit use to the gel pencil end and discard the liquid side. The price is the highest on this list, so the dual-ended value only matters if both ends work for your eyes.
Why it’s great
- Dual-ended design provides both a gel pencil and a liquid felt tip in one product
- Survives extreme weather conditions without smudging or fading
- Vegan and cruelty-free formula for clean beauty routines
Good to know
- Liquid felt tip side irritates sensitive eyes for some users
- Premium price that only delivers full value if both ends are usable
FAQ
What is the difference between a gel eyeliner pencil and a regular kohl pencil?
Can I wear a retractable eyeliner pencil on my waterline without irritation?
How do I stop my eyeliner pencil from smudging on my lower lash line?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best rated eyeliner pencil winner is the Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Gel Liner because it delivers the deepest matte black payoff with bulletproof waterproof wear. If you want a gentle option that glides without pulling on mature or sensitive eyes, grab the IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Retractable Eyeliner. And for a dual-ended tool that handles both pencil and liquid looks from a single tube, nothing beats the tarte double take eyeliner.